Introduction & Objective (research question/aim)
5 points
|
- The introduction strongly demonstrates that the literature has been adequately reviewed.
- The introduction is a strong, clear, and thorough, yet concise, overview to the problem.
- Based on the presented background and knowledge gap, a specific, clear, and testable research objective is stated.
|
- The introduction demonstrates that the literature has been reviewed.
- The introduction is a clear, and somewhat thorough background to the problem.
- Based on the presented background and knowledge gap, a clear and testable research objective is stated.
|
- The introduction partially demonstrates that the literature has been reviewed.
- The introduction provides a clear, and somewhat thorough background to the problem.
- Based on presented background and knowledge gap, a testable research objective is stated.
|
- The introduction very weakly demonstrates that the literature has been reviewed.
- The introduction provides a background that is not informed by aims.
- A clear, but untestable research objective is stated.
|
- The introduction does not demonstrate that the literature has been reviewed.
- The introduction provides a background that is not informed by aims.
- A vague, untestable research objective is stated.
|
- The introduction and research objective are not provided.
|
Materials and Methods
5 points
|
The methods provide a strong and clear explanation of the proposed experimental
methods.
|
The methods provide a clear explanation of the proposed experimental methods.
|
The methods provide an adequate. explanation of proposed experimental
methods.
|
The methods provide an unorganized. explanation of experimental methods.
|
The methods provide an unclear and unorganized explanation of experimental methods.
|
The methods are not provided.
|
Conclusion
5 points
|
The conclusion is fully supported by the study results.
|
The conclusion is mostly supported by the study
results.
|
The conclusion is only partially supported by the study results.
|
The conclusion is weakly supported by the study
results.
|
The conclusion is not supported by the study results.
|
The conclusion is missing.
|